JFFICIAL USE ONL —
some suitable journal to give a more balanced view of the hazards.
Drs. Langham and Hempelmann had sent a letter to the editor of Science
pointing out that there had been a very long follow-up of the small
sample of persons exposed at the Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory.
(As
of the first of March 1972, however, this letter to the editor has not
been published.)
Dr. Burr asked the committee's advice on whether some
attempt should be made to rebut the article that had appeared in Science.
Dr. Moseley felt that a point-by-point rebuttal was not a good idea.
He
felt that the Division of Biology and Medicine had shown good foresight
in anticipating problems with plutonium and that a point-by-point rebuttal
would simply drag out the controversy.
Dr. Haagen-Smit expressed considerable displeasure with the editorial policy of Science
Science is the
official publication for the American Association for the Advancement of
Science and a very small group of staff writers has been writing biased
articles of various scrts which do not necessarily reflect the views of
the membership of the AAAS,
Dr. Moseley pointed out that only the
previous week they had written a very biased article on the value of
chest x-rays.
Dr. Moseley was of the opinion, however, that on the basis
of a meeting he had had with the people from Rocky Flats, that perhaps
some of the criticism might be justified.
Dr. John Totter pointed out that
the management had been changed at the Rocky Flats plant and he considers
this an indication that the Division of Military Application recognizes some
possible deficiencies in the earlier management.
General Giller, from
the Division of Military Application, apparently still does not understand
that the Division of Biology and Medicine does not have a program in Rocky
Flats and is unable to help to the extent that General Giller expects.
The studies at Colorado State University represent the first DBM work that
involves Rocky Flats in any way.
Dr. Lincoln pointed out that only last
fall was there a meeting of medical directors from various AEC installations
to consider the treatment of plutonium exposure.
At the present time,
treatment is on a piece meal basis and Dr. Lincoln feels that better
coordination is required.
Dr. Goldstein replied that at the present time
he is attempting to collate information from the various plants and is attempting to obtain the opinions from the industrial physicians on best methods of
treatment and for action levels which determine when treatment should be
instituted.
Research is continuing on the effectiveness of DTPA, a chelating
agent which presently seems to be the best method of treatment.
The discussion then turned to the question of the size of the work
force at Rocky Flats that might have had significant exposures to plutonium.
Many of these employees have since been terminated.
Dr Burr pointed out
that the plant is sufficiently new that social security numbers could be
obtained to determine whether the terminated work force is living or dead
and a crude estimate of whether there was a significant hazard could be
obtained.
Dr, Totter pointed out that one of the problems faced by DBM has
been a lack of any central coordination concerning the plutonium problem
within the entire AEC,
To rectify this situation, a committee was named with
George Kavanaugh as chairman.
Membership of the committee crossed divisional

-11-

OFFICIAL USE ONLY

Select target paragraph3