29

growth had developed atrophy of the thyroid
gland before puberty, and changes associated with
puberty were delayed. There may be someassociation between the apparent increased demandfor
thyroid hormone at puberty and the appearance

of thyroid nodules, since in 10 children (4 males
and 6 females) thyroid nodules appeared near the
expected or actual time of puberty. In 5 other
children (2 males and 3 females) the nodules appeared | to 3 years after puberty and in the females were associated with pregnancies. In evaluating the influence of puberty and pregnancyit
should be pointed out that the latent period between exposure andthe developmentof thyroid
abnormalities was fairly constant in all these
children, varying between 10 and [3 years, so that
the abovefindings may have beenfortuitous. In
the 4 women who developed carcino:-a of the
thyroid the possible influence of the stress of pregnancy mustbe considered, since al] had multiple
pregnancies in the years preceding the developmentoflesions.
Sex incidence

The sex ratio of occurrence of benign thyroid
lesions in the Rongelap population was 1.3 in females to 1.0*in males. This may be misleading
since, in the group exposed at <10 years of age,

all the females had lesions whereas 2 males did
not. The fact that all 3 malignant lesions of the

thyroid were in females is consistent with reported

statistics showing a preponderance of suchlesions
in females,?6
Discussion

By the time the first malignant thyroid lesion
appearedin the more heavily exposed Rongelap
group several years ago, numerous benign adenomatous thyroid nodules had appeared. The latter
were suspected of being related to the radiation
exposure, but such an etiological relationship of
the single isolated malignant lesion found at that
time was speculative. The finding of 2 additional
individuals with thyroid carcinomain this group
(3 among21 thyroid lesions in 67 Rongelap people
exposed) makes theetiological role of radiation
exposure increasingly probable. For the time being the single malignant thyroid lesion found in
a woman from Utirik Atoll cannot be attributed
to radiation exposure because of the low dose received there.
Thesignificance of radiation exposure of the
thyroid glands in the Rongelap people had not

been fully appreciated until the appearance of
thyroid lesions. More careful review of the dose
calculations indicated that considerable exposures
from radioactive iodine absorption had probably
occurred, particularly in the children. The exposure of the Rongelap people was not comparable
with exposure of populations due to fallout from
reactor accidents in which radionuclides are absorbed chiefly via milk from cattle grazing on con-

taminated pastures. The Marshall Islands have no
cattle and no local milk supply. (Mother’s milk may
have contributed to the radioiodine absorption in

2 children reported to have been nursing at the
time of the accident.) But there was heavy contamination of food and water supplies on Rongelap and a relative abundance of radioiodines in
the fallout. The dose to the thyroid glands was
greater than that to other organs bya factor of 2
in adults and a factor of about 7 in children.
Numerous animalstudies have demonstrated
the role of radiation in the etiology of thyroid
neoplasms.*7-29 In humans the development of
thyroid nodules and cancerfrom x-irradiation,30.31
particularly when the radiation occurs in infancy
and childhood,32-44 is well documented. Develop-

mentof such lesions from radioiodines has also
been seen in animals but less frequently in hu’ mans. Shelineet al.3° reported 8 cases of nodular
goiter in their follow-up study of 250 cases treated
for hyperthyroidism. Six of these cases were irradiated before 20 years of age and 4 before 10
years of age. One showed a possible invasion of
the thyroid capsule.
The incidence of thyroid nodularity in the exposed Marshallese is considerably higher than that
reported by Pincus?? and Hempelmann**in their
studies of populations who had been exposed to
therapeutic x-irradiation of the neck region ata
young age. However,on a risk per rad basis, the incidence of 51 cases per 108 persons per rad per year
for the Marshallese is quite comparable with 24
for one group and 64 for a second group calculated by Pincus and Hempelmann. This comparison seemsto indicate similar effectiveness — per
rad ~ of x-radiation and radioiodine exposure.*
The 3 malignantlesions of the thyroid reported
here in the heavily exposed Rongelap people appear to be the first such cases clearly associated
with radioiodine exposure except for one possibly
malignantthyroid lesion reported by Sheline et al.3°
*Mr. Keith Thompson of this Laboratory carried out the

Statistical analyses in the thyroid cases.

Select target paragraph3