30
Based on the incidence of carcinoma of the thy-

roid among the | 7,000 Marshallese reported by the
Trust Territory, the expected incidence in the
Rongelap high exposure group would be 0.056
cases over the 15-year period. The finding of 3
cases (5.6% incidence) thus represents a considerable increase over the expected number( p<0.01,

x? test). Among the 157 Utirik people about 0.14
cases would be expected, and | case is reported.
It seemsless likely that this single case would involve radiation etiology in view of the low dose
received by this group and the fact that no nodular lesions had been noted among the children.
Based on the present incidence of thyroid malignancy in the high exposure Rongelap group,the
risk of this malignancy developing — per 10% persons
per rad per year — is 3 cases for the children exposed at < 10 years of age, 10 cases for the older
people, and 5.6 cases for the group as a whole. The
risk in the Marshallese children is not inconsistent
with that reported by others.34

——

eer

Radioiodine exposure has been generally con-

sidered less effective than x-radiation in producing thyroid lesions, primarily because few thyroid
tumors have been noted following radioiodinetherapy.26 It seems likely, however, that the scarcity
ofsuch findingsis related to the high doses of radiation used (5000 to 10,000 rads or morein thetreat-

mentof hyperthyroidism and 50,000 rads or more

for ablation of the gland to ameliorate symptoms
in certain diseases). Such doses probably are so destructive that they preclude proliferative activity
and malignant transformation. The increasing
incidence of hypothyroidism without tumorformation, years after treatment of hyperthyroid
patients with radioiodines,illustrates this point.
Tumorformation in animals is not always a dose
dependent phenomenon.*5 Shellabargeret al.36

showed that the incidence of breast tumors in rats

reached a maximum atabout 400 rads andfell off
with higher doses. Lindsayet al.?9 reported thatin
rats doses of 1311 >> 200 to 400 uCi wereless carcin-

ogenic than lower doses. Mark and Bustad reported similar findings in sheep.37 Although the
dose to the thyroid gland in the Marshallese was
generally considerably below the dose of 131] used
for therapy of hyperthyroidism, the doses received
by someof the children were probably above the
optimum carcinogenic range and therefore the
true risk per effective rad maybegreaterin this
group. The paradoxical finding of greater risk in

the older group appears to be in line with this

reasoning. The two stunted Marshallese boys who
showed almost complete atrophy of the thyroid
gland with no evidence of nodular development
are probably comparable with cases of hypothyroidism developing in patients years after
radioiodine therapy. The thyroid exposuresofthe
Rongelapese wereslightly different from those of
patients treated with 131] because their thyroids
were not hyperplastic when exposed, at least part
of the radioiodine isotopes were ofshorter half-life
than 131], and their exposure was complicated by
gammaradiation.
Somefactors secondary to rad... ion exposure

might have enhanced the development of thyroid

lesions in the Marshallese. Iodine deficiency or

goitrogensin the diet did not appear to be among
these. However,the physiologicalstresses of puberty
and pregnancy mayhave played a role in the developmentofthelesions. For instance, the development of 10 cases of nodular goiter in the children
during or nearthe time of puberty mightindicate

that this stress may have enhanced nodularde-.
velopment. In 3 females who later developed thyroid nodules the demand of multiple pregnancies
may have beenrelated. Since the latent period between exposure and nodule discovery varied only
between 10 and 13 years, it may be argued that
developmentof thyroid nodules was independent
of these stresses. On the other handit is noteworthy
that all the women whodeveloped malignant thyroid lesions had had muliple pregnancies.
The occurrence of thyroid nodules in the Marshallese was only slightly higher in females than
in males (ratio of 1.3 to 1.0). This is similar to the
nearly equal sex distribution reported by Toyooka

et al.33 for thyroid nodules developing in persons
irradiated over the neck region in infancy. However, in the case of carcinoma of the thyroid the

expected female preponderance occurred.?&
The insidious development of growth retardation in some of the Marshallese children before
clinical evidence of thyroid abnormality or deficlency was recognized demonstrates the apparent
sensitivity of growth and developmentprocesses to
borderline or subclinical thyroid deficiency. All

possible steps are being taken to help the children
adhereto the present thyroid trez_.nent schedule
so that they will achieve satisfactory growth and
maturation.
Careful medical surveillance of these exposed
people, including the Utirik, will be essential in
future years. The latent period for the develop-

Select target paragraph3