World J. Surg. Vol. 16, No. 1, Jan./Feb. 1992

136

revealed only 4 thyroid operations. One of the 4 was said to
have been a carcinoma (Dr Julian, the surgeon at Majuro
Hospital, personal communication).
As emphasized in this report, there is sometimes difficulty
drawing a distinction between benign and malignant thyroid

neoplasms. The effect of radiation on the thyroid cells adds to

the difficulty because of bizarre nuclear forms which may
develop [13, 16]. Such nuclei may contain excessive amounts of
chromatin not unlike malignant cells [14-16] (Figs. 4, 7 and 8).

Furthermore, the radiation may damage the function of the
gland, causing a decrease in production of thyroid hormone and
a superimposed compensatory stimulus for cell division among

the surviving cells [14]. This may result in cellular hyperplasia
with the formation of papillary structures. It is therefore not
surprising in the case of the Marshallese that pathologists might

disagree about the diagnosis and the potential for some lesions
to metastasize.

Many of the papillary and mixed papillary and follicular
thyroid lesions grow very slowly. Once removedit is impossible
to say what that lesion might have done. The Marshallese

accident has given an unique opportunity to see these thyroid

lesions develop after a single simultaneous event in multiple
individuals. Some lesions were so small that they had not yet
grownto the extent that there was overt invasion of the capsule
or the wall of a blood vessel; yet, the cellular forms sometimes
provided a basis for suspicion that some of these small lesions
had not fully declared their pathophysiologic potential and
spread to lymph nodes. As this experience has evolved, the
occasional uncertainty of the diagnosis at surgery prompted this
surgeon to removeall lymph nodes in the immediate drainage

area of a lobe which contained a lesion in question. It was a

fortuitous finding that in these cases there were 5 instances of
spread to lymph nodes while the primary was only I cm orless
Fig. 9. This female was exposed on Rongelap at age 7. Bilateral subtotal
thyroidectomy, removing all gross nodules, was done at age 22, The
gland displayed many discrete lesions of various size and patterns, the
largest being 1.0 cm. A palpable mass recurred 10 years later. Total
thyroidectomy revealed manysimilar lesions, the largest being 1.5 cm.
No malignant change had occurred in the interval. A variety of small
papillary, solid cellular, and follicular patterns scattered throughout the
gland at the first operation (x25).

outside the fallout area, there were 5 people in this group who
developed masses over the years. One was carcinoma.
It seemed clear that neoplasms sometimes arise spontane-

ously in the Micronesians, as they do in other parts of the

world. A review of the surgery logs at the Majuro Hospital
(which receives patients from the entire Trust Territory) dating
from the early 1960s to the late 1970s, revealed an occasional
thyroidectomy and several carcinomasof the thyroid (personal
review by BMD). Most of these surgical cases came from the
Caroline and Marianna Islands, far west of the fallout area.

Noneof these cases were being cared for by the Marshall Island

Brookhaven Medical Team. Recently Hamilton and coworkers
[29] reported finding thyroid masses in’ people living in more
remote parts of the Marshall Islands. As of March 1989, a
review of thyroid operations logged at the Majuro Hospital for

the i years preceding and following the Hamilton report

gdb

2 eed

in diameter, in 3 cases to only a single lymph node. Many
writers consider such small lesions in the thyroid to be innoc-

uous [17-19, 26, 30]. In this study the circumstances led to the
discovery of carcinomas that seemedto be in an incipient stage

of development. If these small lesions had not been discovered
by the palpation of experts or found incidentally at surgery
(undertaken for what proved to be a benign lesion), it is

reasonable to speculate that the pathological process would

probably have continued until the primary lesion had become
obviously palpable and many nodes by then would have become positive. The latter scenario is the customary finding
encountered in a general surgical experience, where a frank
carcinomais palpably obvious with many positive nodes discovered; just as occurred here in 3 cases where the primary
lesion was large (easily palpable) and many nodes were involved.
Three or more decades ago many observers [24, 26, 31-35]
reported on the multicentric nature of papillary carcinoma of

the thyroid. At that time, the importance of the relationship of

thyroid carcinomato the previoususeof radiation treatment for
thymic hypertrophy and inflammatory disease of the neck had
not been appreciated. Multicentricity was reported to befre-

quent when tiny sites were looked for. The occurrence of

positive nodes was reported to be very high (31, 33, 35; 36].
These were usually more advanced cases in which a clinically

evident mass had drawn attention; however, it was not always

Select target paragraph3