whose thyroid doses ranged from about 400 to
5200 cGy, only 1 of 28 (4%) had the diagnosis of
occult papillary carcinoma.
If only those
Rongelap individuals with doses less than 2000
cGy are analyzed, 1 of 13 (8%) had an occult
carcinoma, and for those receiving over 2000 cGy
the prevalence is 0%.
Therefore, the high
radiation dose received on Rongelap may have
decreased rather that increased the incidence of
the occult tumors.
But a factor that renders any conclusion of

questionable value is that in many of the surgical
explorations the entire thyroid gland was not
removed and subjected to the close histologic
examination that has been used in most studies on
occult papillary carcinoma prevalence.
The
Marshallese data may, therefore, underestimate

the prevalence ofthese lesions, particularly in the
multinodular adenomatousgoiters of the exposed
Rongelap children.
The combined number of occult papillary
carcinomas and overt carcinomasin the Rongelap
and Utirik groupsis virtually identical, being 7.0%
in the former and 6.6% in thelatter:

Rongelap

Exposed persons
Occult CA

86
1

Total CA
Exposed/Total CA

6
7.0%

Overt CA

5

8) Did thyroxine suppression decreage the incidence
of benign and/or malignant nodulq in radiationexposed persons?
Administration of thyroxin for he purpose of
suppression of development of th bid nodules in
Marshallese who had been living o Rongelap at
the time of exposure was initiated
1965 shortly
after the first thyroid nodules
(Conardet al., 1967). The distributi¢
subsequently extended to include tho

suppression. It is given to them onl
indicated as noted below. Every six months a
supply of tabiets is handed out to each exposed
Rongelap person, whether or nd that person
endocrinologic consultants who accompany the
medical team during their work 1 the Marshall
had thyroid surgery under the al
Marshall Islands Medical Program,w
or not, for replacement and suppregsion.

Utirik

167
6
5

11
6.6%

There are proportionally more carcinomas in
the Rongelap group and more occult papillary
carcinomas in the Utirik. One might wonder
whether radiation exposure had the effect of
inducing or hastening a change toward increasing
virulence in the usually benign-acting "occult"
lesions. However, such an interpretation does not
take into account either the limitations on

technique of histological examination of the

thyroid mentioned in the preceding paragraph or
the extensive thyroid injury in those in the
Rongelap group whoreceived more than 2000 cGy
to the thyroid.

Frolund, 1984), and (4) a decrqa
nodules but not malignant nodules (Fogelfeldet al.,
1989). One study found that thyroxfne reduced the
numberof recurrences in those whq had previously
undergone therapy for papillary thyroid carcinoma
(Schneider et al., 1986), although Fhe number of
patients not. given suppressive thegapy was small.
The timing of thyroxine prophylaxis may be an
important factor in determiningits Effectiveness; if
started some years after exposure ifs value may be
lessened (DeGroot et al., 1983).

Any conclusions derived from tlfe results of the

The Rongelap group has been re
suppression since 1965 but it
compliance with this regimen is popr, estimated at
no better than 50% (Adams et al, 1983). The
suppression was not initiated untif 10 years after
23

3f

Select target paragraph3