The Honorable Wallace

July 25, 1980
Page Two

©.

Green

Indeed, we could not even elicit a clear statement

from any Executive Branch official as to the meaning the

Executive Branch would give to the phrase "the people of
such other atolls as may be found to be or to have been
exposed to radiation from the nuclear weapons testing program."
The Department of Energy officials present conceded
that every atoll in the Marshall Islands was exposed to some
level of radiation as a consecuence of the nuclear weavens testing program.
Furthermore, these same officials conceded
that since precise measurements were not taken on all the
Marshall Islands atolls at the time, there simplv is no way
of knowing how much radiation exposure occurred that woulc
have acced to the radiation body-burden of the residents
livine throughout the Marshall Islands at the time of the
nuclear weapons testing program.
Likewise,

it was

conceded by

these

same officials

that tnere was simply no way to determine whether any particular
adverse health effects experienced by anv particular Marshallese

citizen related directly or indirectly to radiation exposure

from the nuclear weapons testing program.
Finally, these
same officials also conceded that it would be far more
costly to attempt to prove or disprove the relationship
between radiation exposure and health effects in the Marshall
Islands for cny partic:clar individual than simvly to provide
comprehensive health care for those Marshallese individuals
that suffer acverse health effects.
It was further acknow-

lecgec that it would be highly unethical to construct a

major medical

facility

in

the Marshall

Islands

to

carry out

the statutory mandate and then deny a Marshall Islands
-Citizen suffering adverse health effects access to such a
medical facility when the United States and indeed no one
could Getermine with certainty that such adverse health

effects did not relate directly or indirectly to the nuclear

weapons testing program.

All of these factual concessions, it seems to me,
must inevitably lead to the reasonable conclusion that
Congress intended to provide health care for persons of all
atolls “exposed to radiation from the nuclear weapons testing program" when it enacted that legislative language.
Despite this obvious, sensible Concressional intention, no one
in yvrur Department was prepared to agree that the phrase
“exposed to radiation from the nuclear weapons testing
program” means "exposed to radiation from the nuclear weapons
testing program.”

Select target paragraph3