4
oe eevee erties Ae ge eg

25 first observed nine years after exposure among these people. By
zen of Sixty-eignt, of the most heavily expcsed nad develcped nodules whi
fficient concern to require exploration. Cne carcincma had been found.
© of the survey early in 1969, five iscre individuals in this pepulation
to have developec thyrcid masses Watch we felt should be explered. Far
the more heavily expcsed group on Ponszelap atoll, i.e. several hundred 7

ancred rads estimated dose to the thyroid; and one on Utirik atoll who }
sceived 30 rads. These were brought back to the U.S. for snecial study
fen National Laboratory. Because of our interest in and labcratory studi
3 thyroids, the patients were brought to our institution in September,
al exploration. Three of the five proved to heve lesions of the th,
malignant (two Rongelap; one Utirik). One of these had extensive regi
. A fourth patient possessed several nedules, one of which was very sm
smpted serlous consideration that this might also be malignant. Autcorade
Lavely prepared in additicn to a variety of observations commenly made
m our animals (not 3H-thymidine).

Several of these thyroids had many mh

ilar hyperplastic lesicns, none of wnich took up significant anounts cf
2. Many of the lesions were papillary in structure and suggested papil
uiticentric origin.

All of these thyroids (except the woman from Uti

large bizarre nuclear forms repeatedly observed under this contract in

1 humans that had received

I.

om was made in the past annual report cf a preliminary review of the Ma

ssues for evidence of radiation effect based primarily on the bizarre n

xtner subtle changes as observed in rats and human thyroid tissue.
just been completed in a formal manner.

Thi

snellese
lear

3st the validity of these criteria as evidence cf radiation effect, Dr.
ard of Brockhaven National Laboratory assembled multiple sliijes of each
the Marshallese, of some thyroids of Japanese atcmic bomb casualties,
> the Utah-Nevada children who may have been exposed (mentioned elsewhe
rort - from Dr. Marvin Rallison) and of miscellaneous unexposed nodular
dliected from elsewhere in Utah. More than 100 individual slides, comp
is to identity, were submitted to this writer for review and appraisal
7 radiation effect in them. All slides. were graded as to positive orn
F radiation effect, and where positive, the evidence was further graded
, t+, or +++; + being the slightest evidence and +++ being pronounced ey
vidual slides were graded and reported to Dr. Conard, multiple slides t
com the same thyroid were grouped together (still as unknowns) and
1. Although in most cases the ratings on several slides from the same
were similar, it was appropriate to affix a single rating to each th
was the rating changed more than one degree to arrive at a common rati
1 thyroid. The results show that all of the Marshallese except one we
as having received radiation exposure. Among these was a Marshallese
2n exposed and several years later had died of other causes on Majuro a
st mortem provided the tissue which was free of gross Acdularity. Sev
cposed thyroids and a few of the Utah-Nevada group were graded as doubt
mise of the correlation of the observations, Dr. Conard subsequently ob
jual theoretical records of rad dose delivered to the thyroid (based on [body
2cmined scme days after the removal of the Marshallese people from Rong
ef change attributed to radiation effect in the thyroids proved to co
Most
ingly precise fashion with the degree of exposure previously calculated}
pldced
have
observers
some
as
unese tissues were graded only + or G. Where
le weight of evidence for radiation effect upon the presence of lymphocytes,

Select target paragraph3