trapolation to very low radiation levels establishes the maximum value that may reasonably be
expected, but it does not preclude the possibility that there may be no effect at all insofar as
somatic effects are concerned.
4.2

Genetic Damage

Genetic damage from Sr*° is generally accepted as negligible because this element does
not concentrate in the reproductive organs. There may be, however, some minor effect from
its presence in the circulating blood or even from incorporation into the chromosomes themselves. Until more is known about such possibilities, calculations about genetic damage must
continue to be based on the increase of background radiation due to long-lived gamma-rayemitting isotopes in the fallout. It is estimated in the NAS report that in the United States the
accumulated 30 year dose will be about 0.1 r, if weapons testing continues at the average rate
of the previous five years. If the dose corresponding to the spontaneous mutation rate (doubling

dose) in man is 50 r in 30 years (30 to 80 r is mentioned as the probable range in the NAS report), this means that the mutation rate will be increased by 0.2 per cent. Even if the doubling
dose were aslittle as 10 r, which is probably the reasonable minimum,the increase would
only amount to 1.0 per cent.
In the NAS report it is stated that 2 per cent of the total live births in the United States
have tangible defects of genetic origin that appear prior to sexual maturity. According to

genetic principles, it may be expected that the number of such defective individuals will

ultimately be increased by 0.2 to 1.0 per cent of the present frequency by the predicated increase in background radiation resulting from gammaray fallout. There are approximately
4,000,000 children born alive per year in the United States. The ultimate increase in geneti-

cally defective children will therefore be 0.2 to 1.0 per cent of 4,000,000 (160 to 800 per year
as compared to 80,000 per year resulting from the spontaneous mutation rate). One may get
larger absolute numbers by extending the calculation to the world’s population of 2.7 billion.
Assuming the same birth rate and the same estimated gonad dose of 0.1 r in 30 years as for

the United States, the ultimate world-wide increase of defective children is 2500 to 13,000 per
year. It should be noted that this is the ultimate increase; that is, the increase that would
occur if the additional 0.1 r in 30 years persisted for a great many generations. In the first

+ Sitti

generation, the increase might amount to 10 per cent of the ultimate value. If the radiation
from fallout were not to continue after the first generation, the manifestation of mutations
would continue to increase for some generations and then would gradually return to the initial

level. It should be noted also that the world-wide average increase in background radiation

ascribable to fallout, is considerably lower than in the United States. Therefore, the above

world-wide estimates are definitely too high, by a considerable factor.

The NAS report also stresses the conclusion that in any evaluation of genetic damage the
total damage must include the effects of many mutations that do not produce tangible defects,
at least when inherited from only one parent. The total damage, in fact, is more nearly equal

to the frequency of mutations induced. The NAS report gives the estimates of six geneticists
on the Committee that the induced mutation rate is probably about 0.5 per cent per roentgen

per individual. If this figure is used as the basis of calculation, the total number of detrimental
mutations induced by a gammaray fallout dose of 0.1 r would be 2000 in the United States and
32,000 for the entire world, in contrast to a spontaneous frequency 100 to 800 times higher.
4.3.

Leukemia

It is well known from animal experiments and from observations on humansthat exposure
to radiation in sufficient amounts induces leukemia in susceptible individuals. That some sort

of susceptibility of unknown nature (perhaps genetic) is involved in the process, is evident from
the study by W. M. Court Brown and R. Doll (Medical Research Council report) of the incidence

of leukemia in ankylosing spondylitis patients treated with x-rays. Of the patients treated with
maximum bone marrow doses of 2750 r or more, 0.176 per cent developed leukemia.
Neither the above mentioned study nor any other made so far provides the necessary in-

formation to decide whether there is a threshold dose that must be exceeded before leukemia
is induced in man, but some animal experiments indicate the existence of a threshold. Also,
the absence of a threshold is considered doubtful by most authorities in the field of hematology.

272

;

Select target paragraph3