The results support the notion that external risk coefficients are
different from internal risk coefficients following exposure to a mixed
radiation field. The total risk coefficients [3.0xl0
(#4.5x1
) cancers
per person-rad-year at risk, 10-year latent period, and 2.3x10
(+3.5x10 ~)
cancers per person-rad-year at risk, 5-year latent period] are similar to the
literature values (1,2) for this age distribution and for external exposure »
The literature values are 2.1x10° for a 10-year latent period and 1.9x10
for a S-year latent period. However, if the risk is examined as a function of
age or as a function of dose, differences are encountered. For example, the
ratio of the risk coefficient for external exposure to the risk coefficient
for internal exposure, in the <10 year age group, is 2.5 (0.38 to 4.6).
In
the 10- to 18-year age group, this risk coefficient ratio is 9.40 (0.22 to
2.6).
Small group size, in this study, and the uncertainties reported in
studies on medical and fallout exposures make it difficult to establish relative risks of thyroid cancer from internal and external radiation doses to the
thyroid. The possible synergistic effect of internal and external exposures

and the modifying factors such as high TSA levels and nonuniform irradiation
of thyroid cells compiicate the biological tnterpretation of the risk.
In

this study, different age groups correspond to different dose levels, and very

high dose to the thyroid may be a significant modifying factor.
Because of
the high interest in evaluating human sensitivity to
I, continued efforts

are needed to obtain data and to conduct analyses that will establish better
estimates of risk coefficients than are now available.
It is not likely that
data for the Marshallese exposures will contribute to the answer to that
important question.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors fully appreciate the efforts of John Baum, Associate Head for
Research in the Safety and Environmental Protection Division, for his review
of this manuscript.
This work was performed by members of Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Associated Universities, Incorporated, under contract No. DE~ACO2-76CHO0016
with the United States Department of Energy, and under contract No. YOL-CP40503 with the National Cancer Institute.
REFERENCES
1. Committee on the Biological Effects of Ionizing Radiation, The Effects on
Populations of Exposure to Low Levels of Ionizing Radiation:
1980,
National Research Council Report,

1980.

2.

National Academy Press, Washington, DC,

Recommendations of the National Council on Radiation Protection and
Measurements, Induction of Thyroid Cancer by Ionizing Radiation, NCRP
Report No.80, Bethesda, MD, 1985.

3. Lessard, E.T., R.P. Miltenberger, R.A. Conard, $.V. Musolino, J.R. Naidu,
A. Moorthy, and C.J.

Schopfer, Thyroid Absorbed Dose for People at

Rongelap, Utirik and Sifo on March 1, 1954, Brookhaven National Laboratory
Report, Upton, NY, BNL 51882, 1985.

29

Select target paragraph3