140

M. Brucer

does is to distort the spectrum of radioactivity so that the detector sees a different kind
of radiation from what it would see if the
source were in free air. If the phantom distorts the spectrum in a mannerdifferent from
the way the neck distorts the spectrum, then
the measurements of the total number of
counts detected will be different. Therefore,
the phantom must be designed to give off
a spectrum similar to that of the patient's

neck.. The misuse of phantoms and the use
of improperly designed phantoms accounts
for about one quarter of the potential error
in those laboratories where spectrometers are
used for thyroid uptake.
In some laboratories formulas have been
devised with very careful attention to detail
so that measurements on all of their hyper-

thyroid patients are correctly calibrated to
a reasonable answer. However, when a hypo-

thyroid patient with a high body background
Is inserted into this system of measurement,

a very false answer is achieved. The use of
queer and unusual formulas accounts for a

significant portion of the error in those laboratories where spectrometers are used for
thyroid uptake.
Among those persons who used spectro-

meter it was unusual that the size, shape, or

kind of standard caused any error. Usually
the laboratories sufficiently advanced to use
a spectrometer made very good calibrations

of their standards. The only argument that
would ensue in a laboratory using a spectro-

meter would be the argument on the estimate of absolute microcurie values.
But very few laboratories used a spectrometer for the measurement of thyroid uptake. Most laboratories used instruments in

which there was no possible control over the

spectrum seen by the instrument. In these
laboratories the major source of error in thy-

roid uptake measurements was in the use of

an improperly designed phantom or the use
of no phantom at all. The phantom design
alone accounts for the largest portion, about
50 per cent, of the error. Even whena stan-

Acta Radiolégica
Interamericana

dard phantom is used, however,it is still possible to make considerable error in the thyroid uptake measurement. It would appear

that the formula used to determine the per
cent uptake in the neck accounts for the next
largest portion-about 25 per cent. With many
instruments the size and shape of the 100

per cent total dose standard is very impor-

tant. Those persons who used a very small

standard, for example a gelatin capsule in

air, invariably gave very incorrect answers.

Those persons who used very large standards,

for example 100 cc of water in a paper cup,
usually gave fairly accurate answers in the
high-thyroid, low body-background type of
patient. They invariably, however, had very
incorrect answers in the low-thyroid, high
body-background type of patient. The size

and shape of the standard appears to account

for about 20 per cent of the error when all
types of machines are taken into considera-

tion.
Most of the other elements of variation

accounted for a very small portion of
error in thyroid uptake measurement.
example, the area covered by the filters,
type of collimation, the distance used,

the
For
the
the

thickness of various filters, the materials used

in manufacturing the filter — all of these factors were relatively minor. The distance
factor, however, brought up a different ques-

tion. In many laboratories the most important single source of error was the sloppiness

with which the distance was measured. Almost any distance, provided it is neither too
close nor too far from the patient, can be

used adequately to measure thyroid uptake.
However, the distance between the detector

and the patient and the detector and the
standard must beeither identical or in a precisely constant ratio. This is a very critical

measurement and is one that is not appreciated by most of the technicians who are

doing thyroid uptake measurement. During
the survey of thyroid uptake measurments it
was found that many laboratories did not use
any device for determining distance.

Select target paragraph3