In summary, hypothyroidism and subclinical
thyroid hypofunction, benign thyroid nodule
formation, thyroid surgery with its attendant
risks and complications, an excessive preva-

to be significantly diminished thyroid reserve in
many exposed persons, and, although this diminution is not apparent from routine TSH testing, it frequently may be made clinically significant by thyroid surgery. The extent of the
problem cannot be accurately assessed with the
data at hand becauseof the variability in compliance with the taking of the prescribed thyroxin suppression, and because no clinical
benefit would accrue to the exposed population
from discontinuing thyroxin for the purpose of
proving the point. Nevertheless, a 61% prevalence of postsurgical thyroid hypofunction is
reason for great concern in view of the high
frequency of benign thyroid nodules in the
exposed population.
D. Postsurgical hypoparathyroidism:
In two thyroid surgery patients transient
postsurgical hypocalcemia was observed. However, two other Rongelap women developed
chronic hypoparathyroidism requiring replacement therapy since undergoing thyroid surgery.
In one the deficiency was diagnosed postoperatively and has not resolved. In the other the
diagnosis was first made.twenty years following
surgery. Both surgeries were performed on
Guam during the early yearsof the medical program. Postsurgical hypoparathyroidism is not
an unusual complication of extensive thyroid
surgery, occurring in up to 20% of patients. However, in experienced hands the frequency of
postsurgical hypoparathyroidism is much lower.

lence of thyroid hypofunction after thyroid

surgery, and possibly pituitary tumors can be
considered adverse delayed consequences of
radiation injury in the exposed Marshallese. The
tally comes to 85 morbid events in 253 persons.
In contrast, the only evidence for a “stochastic”
effect of radiation exposure has been an
increase in thyroid cancers in the Rongelap
population, none of whom yet have evidence of
residual disease. While several nonthyroidal
cancers known to be inducible in humans by
external ionizing radiation have been documented in the exposed population, similar
cancers have occurred in the unexposed Comparison population of Marshallese. Therefore,
one may conclude that in the Marshallese experience the delayed expression of nonmalignant
morbidity due to irradiation has indeed been
great and far exceeds that of malignant disease.

REVIEW OF CANCERIN THE
COMPARISON POPULATION
In earlier BNL publications neoplasms of the
exposed population were comparedto those of
an unexposed “Comparison” population with a
similar age and sex distribution. However, since
the last report, which brought the period of
medical coverage up to December 31st, 1984,
concerns have been voiced about present-day
safety of habitation on Rongelap island. An
analysis of the current radiation risk of Rongelap habitation is not a function of the Marshall
Islands Medical Program, which is a clinical program devoted to aspects of health care for persons acutely exposed to radioactive fallout in
1954. Nevertheless, medical information collected over many years concerning the unexposed Rongelap people has been requested by
different groups who are involved in assessing
that risk. To assist them and others who may
wish to review the medical experience of the
Comparison population, a summary of diagnoses of neoplastic disease is presented here. It
is essential to realize that whatever radiation
risk exists today on Rongelap is quite distinct
from that incurred by 86 Rongelap inhabitants
and 167 Utirik inhabitants during the two-day
exposure to Bravo fallout in 1954. The reasons
for this statement are given below.

E. Laryngeal nerve injury:
One Rongelap man has a mild but definite
impairment in speech resulting from recurrent
laryngeal nerve injury, a well-known complication of thyroid surgery. This is not a common
complication, occurring in perhaps 1% of
patients. As with postsurgical hypoparathyroidism, its frequency dependsgreatly on the experience of the surgeon and the extent of the
surgery.
F. Pituitary tumor formation:
Two women exposed as young children, one
from Rongelap and one from Utirik, have developed pituitary tumors. These tumors are usually benign, causing disease, in part, because of
their expansion inside a rigid structure. Thereis
no knowndirect association between radiation
exposure and development of pituitary tumor,
but there are reasons to suspectthat pituitary
tumor formation may be a consequence of thyroid injury (Adamsetal., 1984).
17

Select target paragraph3