On the basis of Stewart's prediction of 300-800 excess cancers
per 106 person-rads, the Japanese should have shown 10.5 to 28
cases/35,000 person-rads.
The observed number of cases was

one.

Storer pointed out that this is the third major prospective study
that has

been unable to demonstrate an increased risk of cancer from

in utero radiation, whereas nearly all retrospective studies show a
significant association.
Miller again voiced the argument he presented so well in his
article in Science (166: 569-574, 1969), namely that retrospective studies
of the Stewart type may contain a systematic error which has so far been
impossible to identify.
Dr. Finch raised the question of whether it might be possible to
obtain Stewart's data for further study by DBM.
Dr. Miller suggested that
similar data by Dr. McMahmmight be more easily obtained.
Dr. Cohen
warned against any out-of-hand dismissal of the results of retrospective
studies,
Mr. Joe Dea* of the DBM staff reported on civil defense studies concerning the status of the U.S. shelter program as compared to the rest
of the world.
The U.S. is apparently considerably behind the rest of the
world in dual use shelter planning.
The report of the study will go to
the National Security Agency for a committee to consider it.
Mr. Deal
argues quite plausibly that new construction should consider incorporating
shelters.
This approach will provide shelters much less expensivly than
if shelters have to be built later.
He also described in some detail the aerial radiological monitoring
survey program. This program, which is supported by DBM, recently located
a missile for the Department of Defense.
The missile had missed its
targeted area in Southern New Mexico and had landed in the Mexican desert.
At the last moment the AEC was called in and was able to pinpoint the
impact site using the aerial radiological monitoring system.
Dr. Wood of the DBM staff described the current status of phosphor
development by the Lockheed Company under contract to DBM.
Dr. Wood also
described the current status of the negative pi-meson facility at the Los
Alamos Scientific Laboratory.
At the moment there are no funds allocated
for a Bio-Medical Facility in connection with the pi-meson program.
Unless
funding is forthcoming to construct an area for biomedical research, then
either no biomedical research can be done or the entire facility would
necessarily have to be shut down for a prolonged period of time at a later
date to enable such construction.

Select target paragraph3