gentiower: Papers, Lye s-OdL | LASSI eei wTFEr as . Pag (Ann Whitman file) at 2,8 o ~~ 7 _ Secretary Quarles reported that the Joint Chiefs of Staff had tried to take into account the point which the President had just made, but that they had concluded that after a devastating nuclear attack all the Free World nations would need every merchant vessel left to them or that they were in a position to build. The President then suggested his second question. Should we not commence with an estimate of the requirements for merchant shipping set by commercial and trade considerations, rather than beginning with en estimate of the requirements for shipping posed by considereticns of national defense? Turning to the Acting Secretary of Commerce, the Fresident asked him whether he could describe a reasonable program of replacements of merchant vessels, looking at the fFroblem from the point of view of trade and commerce. Secretary Williams replied that he couldn't answer the President's question precisely, and that it would be very difficult to distinguish between the level of ships required by commercial consideraticns and that required for national defense. . . The National Security Council: a. Noted and discussed the subject in the light of the ,enclosures to the reference memoranda of October 9 and December 10, 1957, with particular reference to the Record of Action of Defense Mobilization Board Meeting No. 139, conteined in Exhibit B enclosed with the reference memorandum of October 9. Io’ ( The Fresident went on to easy that he wes by no means sure that the necessary accurate assumptions on requirements were being made by the Joint Chiefs of Staff. He therefore sugesested that a new approach be made, beginning with an estimate of the commercial requirements for the U. S. merchant marine. After arriving at this estimate, the Defense Department should consider how much of its military requirements could be obtained from this commercial fleet together with the fleets cf allied nations. The figure of 1200 ships didn't mean very much in itself to the Fresident. Concurred, in accordance with the recommendation of the Defense Mobilization Board, thet; "The policy that an adequate merchant marine is essential for defense purposes should be reaffirmed. Under latest planning concepts, there is a continuing need for a modern, adequate, and well-balanced U. S. merchant marine fleet.” c. Neted that the Defense Mobilization Board at its 139th meeting had recommended, and the Director, Office of Defense Mobilization, had approved, the recognition of a stated interim mobilization bese goal for the active “3 VAGLASOi Ee" ep. r

Select target paragraph3