ceived thyroid irradiation in 1954 seems to conform
in a general way to the concepts outlined above.
Radiation appears to have been the cause of the
thyroid ibnormalities seen, since 200 natives of the
same ethnicbackground and living under identical

conditions showed no thyroid disease. Furthermore,

there is no evidence that these people have been
exposed to other factors that might cause pathologic

changes in the gland: urinalyses indicate that the
iodine intake. is adequate, and no dietary goitro-

genic factors have been implicated. In addition, the
data in the present study show a much greater incidence of thyroid disease in children than in adults
in accord with the findings cited above. This yreater
sensitivity of infants may also be related to the relative magnitudes of the dose of radiation received,
the infant gland probably receiving five to ten times
the radiation dose that an averayge adult's gland
received. The dose range of from 700 to 1400 rads
delivered to the children’s thyroid glands is similar
to the doses received during thymic irradiation. The
apparently greater incidence of pathologic changes
in the glands of the Marshallese is not clear. It may
be related to a greater dose of radiation received by
the Marshallese since the calculations for thyroid
dose in these people is subject, as noted above, to
large uncertainties.

There appears to be an increased incidence . of
thyroid carcinoma in inhabitants of Hiroshima and
Nayasaki exposed to radiation from the atomic-bomb
explosions. The numbers are small, however, com-

The treatmentof the exposed group with levothyroxine deserves some further comment. Bielschow-

sky*® and Astwood and Cassidy™® have reviewed the

favorable effects of thyroid treatment of patients
with nodules of the thyroid gland. The only experimental evidence found directly: applicable to the
Marshallese situation is a paper by Nichols et al.
and unpublished data by Godwin™® demonstrating a
reduced incidence of [!-induced adenomas in rats
treated with thyroid hormone. This form oftreatment, therefore, seems reasonable in the Marshallese.

The implications of the present findings are twofold. In the first place, contrary to previous concepts, the quantity of radioisotopes of iodine in
fallout of the close-in type associated with atomicbomb detonations must be regarded as a major longterm hazard. Secondly, the development of hypothyroidism, of thyroid adenomatoid lesions and of a
thyroid carcinoma after doses of radioiodine that
deliver 300 to 1400 rads to the gland makes caution in
the use of radioiodine necessary
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS

Pathologic changes in

the thyroid gland were

found in a number of Marshallese people of Ronye-

lap Island who were accidentally exposed to radioactive fallout in 1954. Definite thyroid nodules were
noted in 1] people, minimal changes in 5 others,
and hypothyroidism in 2. All but 1 case occurred in

the more heavily exposed population (55 living of
the original 64 persons), who received about 175
rads of whole-body gamma radiation, burns of the
almost 15,000 individuals, as compared to 2 cases in
slightly less than 5000 unexposed individuals.* _ skin from fallout products and internal absorption of
fission products. One case with a nodule was noted
These people were exposed to varying doses ‘of
in an adult woman in the smaller Ronyelap ygroup
external radiation to the thyroid gland but not to
(16 of the 18 are still alive) that had received less
internal exposure from radioiodine.
than half the exposure of the other group. In 200
The growth retardation previously noted in some
individuals of a control proup not exposed no such
of the exposed children has been assumed to be
thyroid abnormalities were found. In the more
due to the radiation, but the mechanism has not

i

teresting that the exposedyirls have shown verylittle

retardation of growth and development although the
nodules are more prevalent among them. Except for

the 2 boys with hypothyroidism, the rest of the chil-

heavily exposed

group,

thyroid abnormalities de-

veloped in 55 per cent of children exposed at less
than ten years of age. Five children were found at
surgery to have benign adenomatous goiters. The 1

adult patient had a mixed papillary and follicular

carcinoma, with localized metastasis. Two boys
showed marked retardation of prowth, apparently
owing to primary hypothyroidism.

dren with growth retardation have shown normal pro-

. The radiation etiology in these cases appears to
be reasonably certain in view of the following facts:

enough to account for the growthretardation seen. The
finding of high TSH levels in the 2 most retarded boys

radiation (adults about 300 rads, and children about
700 to 1400 rads); and the incidence of thyroid ab-

tein-bound iodine and cholesterol values. Minimal
hypothyroidism may have been missed and may be

with hypothyroidism and slight elevation in 2 other
retarded children strongly indicates primary hypothyroidism. The growth response of these children after
thyroid feeding will offer an interesting therapeutic
test of the hypothyroid etiology of the growth retardation.

5012902

the thyroid glands received a substantial dose of
radiation from radioiodines and external gamma

normalities was high in the exposed group and ab-

sent in an unexposed control population living on

the same island.
The present findings suggest that the seriousness
of the internal hazard associated with fallout, particularly from radioiodine, must be revised upward.

PRIVACY ACT MATERIAL REMOVED

ee

been known.? With the recent development of frank
hypothyroidism in 2 of the most retarded boys in
the exposed yvroup hypothyroidism seems the most
likely cause. In 2 other retarded boys (
and
)
thyroid nodules have developed. However, it is in-

eeie ee eee eee

AUNMattes ot ag Rte 0+e RRATTI

prising 19 cases in a combined exposed yroup of

Select target paragraph3