92

Harold L. Atkins

28 patients failed to control the hyperthyroid state in 25. It is interesting that 3
patients did become euthyroid with doses of 400, 600, and 800 rads. The trial was
then abandoned.

The advantage of external beam irradiation is the rather precise control of
radiation dose. This permits the depletion of a specified fraction of thyroid cells, a
situation not possible with an internally deposited radionuclide.

Trotter and Willoughbyhave demonstrated a biphasic effect of radiation on
thyroidal radioiodine uptake following a dose of 400 to 800 rads of ®°Co gamma
rays on a portion of the thyroid. There is an initial 30 to 50 percent reduction in
uptake, demonstrated on scans, which occursat an interval of 24 hours between
irradiation and administration of the dose. A slight compensatory increase in
uptake is then noted for 2 weeks followed by a second decrease in uptake at 3
weeks lasting for about 2 weeks.

Fifty patients were treated with radioiodine following irradiation of a portion
of the gland with 800 rads in the hope that the portion of the gland temporarily
suppressed by ®°Co would take up less of a therapeutic dose of I and thus be
spared destruction. However, no difference in the rate of hypothyroidism was
noted in the early results at less than I year. Further details have not been published.

With the development of accurate methods for localizing charged particle

beams, there is the possibility of using the Bragg peak for precise delineation of a
target area within the thyroid while sparing normal tissue. With such a beam of
heavy ions it would be possible to selectively irradiate a portion of the thyroid
while sparing the remainder, as well as adjacent normal tissues. This approach has
not yet been undertaken.
Use of 125]

The highly energetic beta emission combined with the gamma photons of!"]
results in a rather uniform distribution of the radiation dose in the individual

thyroid cell. Since, as stated above, the reproductive capacity of thyroid cells is
more radiosensitive than the functional aspect, it seems very unlikely that reduc-

tion of the functional integrity can occur following ''I without subsequentcell

death and eventual hypothyroidism.
With "5] the situation is theoretically quite different. Most of the radiation
effect is probably due to the very low energy conversion and Auger electrons.***!

The lower energy Augerelectrons (0.8-2.9 kev) are particularly abundant (Table
6-1). The range of these electrons in tissue is very small (from < 0.4 to 20 wm).

Since the radioiodine is primarily in the colloid, the radiation dose distribution is
markedly nonhomogeneous, affecting the cellular cytoplasm at the apex ofthe cell

to a much greater extent than the nucleus (Fig. 6-2).
Dose estimates for whole-gland distribution can be in serious error relative to

the microscopic distribution. Difficulties in calculation are evident because of the

marked variation in follicle size and cell size in the normal and hyperthyroid gland.
Several authors have made such calculations,**5* and these have shown ratios of
about 3-4 to 1 for the colloid-cell interface dose to the dose at the nucleus (Table

Ci

a

crn

6-2).

Theoretically this concentration of dose at the colloid-cell interface should

Select target paragraph3