IN CONFIDENCE

-7-

of the relevant period of exposure.
The estimates of internal exposure in the initial phases depend
upon three types of assumption:

(i)
The size of the thyroid glands into which the radioactive
iodine was concentrated, and the way in which gland size varies with
age.
Estimates of gland size made in different countries do not
vary greatly, and che sizes assumed for the lfarshallese children, in
the absence of direct data,

are typical average values.

(ii)
The types of radioiodine taken into the body, and whether
by inhalation, drinking water or food (since this affects the time
and duration of exposure).
The types of radioiodine present at any
time since nuclear fission are well established on physical grounds,
and the assumed modes and durations of intake seem reasonable.
(iii)

The amount of these radioiodines incorporated in the

thyroid and hence the radiation exposure of glands of any given size.

niere the estimate nas to be based on measurements of the amounts
excreted in pooled urine specimens taken 15 days after exnosure, and
on assumptions as to the proportion of the initial uptake that will be
excreted during this 15th day. Tne original assumption was that 9.95
to 0.2% of the initial uptake would be excreted on that day.
I have
recalculated this figure on the basis of the best later estimates of
which I am aware for the speed of discharge of iodine from the normal
thyroid and its apnearance in the urine, and obtain a figure of %.097,
in good agreement with the central value for the original assumptions.
I have also seen a calculation by Dr. Rall and Dr. Berman based directly
on measurements of iodine turnover in five Marshallese people.
This
gives a higher percentage, and therefore a lower estimate of radiation
exposure as based on the measured urinary excretion.
It should also be
added that, if the thyroid radiation itself altered any of these (normal)
values, it would do so by accelerating the discharge of iodine from the
gland, and perhaps also by increasing the proportion excreted in the
urine.
Both these changes would thus lower the estimate of thyroid dose.
The average thyroid dose may thus have been lower than estimated, and
it seems unlikely to have been higher.
It must be emphasized however
that tnese are estimates of the likely average dose from internal
radiation.
Doses received by different children are likely to have
differed considerably from the average appropriate for their age, owing
to individual variations in size of gland, in amount of contaminated
water drunk, or air inhaled, and in the discnarge rate of iodine from
the thyroid gland.
I apologize for the considerable length of this report and
recognize that much of it deals with minor points of technical or medical
detail.
I felt however that, on questions of the type which your
1
Committee has raised and with which it must be concermed, it tras

[014831

eee

/ continued...

Select target paragraph3