Volume 66, No. 6

June 1967

LATE EFFECTS OF RADIOACTIVE IODINE IN FALLOUT

tively small number of genes regulating the
synthesis of proteins responsible for thyroid

cell function. Cell division in the adult thy-

roid gland occurs very rarely, and mitosis

is almost never seen in histological sections
of the normal gland. Consequently, the
lethal mutation may not be evident for a
very long time. After many years, the cell

begins to divide and perishes in the process.
The cumulative effect of cell death could

readily account for the observed accrual of

hypothyroid cases at the rather steady rate
of about 2%/year of those treated.

Thus, it is not unexpected to find that
hypothyroidism developed insidiously in
certain of the exposed Marshallese children.
The radiation dose was not so large as to
cause extensive cell destruction in the acute
phase, but only later did the injured cells
succumb.

The two clearly hypothyroid Marshallese
children, like patients developing hypothyroidism after radioiodine therapy for hyperthyroidism, did not have any goiter forma-

tion. Evidently, the cells are sufficiently injured in these instances so that they fail

to respond to the influence of the excess

TSHsecretion that must accompanyfalling
thyroid function. This phenomenon was

demonstrated directly by Doniach (23) who
showed that rats treated with 30 yc 3811, or
1,100 rads by X rays, failed to develop
goiter when treated briefly with propylthiouracil. Maloof, Dobyns, and Vickery (24)
also observed this phenomenon and postulated that, since the stimulated glands
showed cellular hypertrophy but no increase in weight, there must have been an
impairment of the ability of such irradiated
cells to divide.
In the spectrum of radiation dosage to

thyroid cells, one might expect to find the
situation in which the cell’s function is
partially impaired but its growth potential
is not. Alternatively, unequal damage to
cells in the same gland mayresult in some
with impaired function and growth potential and others with less severe injury. The

1237

net result could be the development of
mild hypothyroidism or the maintenance
of euthyroidism only as a result of con-

tinued overstimulation by TSH. Under

such circumstances, those cells capable of
responding may grow and multiply. Furthermore, if the radiation has produced a
nonlethal mutation, the progeny ofthe cell
may be abnormal.

This chain of events appears responsible

for the majority of the cases of thyroid abnormality among the Marshall Islanders

and is found in animals treated with appropriate doses of radioiodine especially
when further stimulated by low-iodine diet
or antithyroid drugs (19, 20). As pointed
out in connection with the histological
findings, the thyroid glands of the exposed :
Marshallese children showed results charac- }
teristic of excessive and prolonged thyroid |
stimulation.

Such

stimulation,

with

or

without preceding irradiation, leads to the

formation of thyroid nodules with a wide

variety of histological cell types. Nodular
goiter formation of this sort, however, is

not limited to children. The explanation
for the high prevalence of goiter in the
children and the much lowerprevalence in
the exposed adults is most likely attribut-

able to the fact that the small thyroid

glands of the children received a larger,
and hence more destructive, dose of radiation.

Sheline, Lindsay, McCormack, and Ga-

lante (25) also found in their follow-up of
patients treated with thyroid radiation for
thyroid disease that of the 8 patients developing thyroid nodules out of a total of
256, 6 had been irradiated before the age
of 20 years and 4 before the age of 10
years. Indeed, the latter 4 represented two
thirds of all those treated at an age younger
than 10 years. Most of them had multiple
nodules, much as were found in the Marshall Islanders. It may be that these
younger subjects actually received larger
radiation doses than the older ones. On the
other hand, this seems unlikely to be the

Select target paragraph3