Note 12

PLUTONIUM ANALYSIS

In the case of radionuclides that emit beta rays (strontium-90) or
alpha particles (transuranics), and whose range in tissue is at most a
centimeter down to some micrometers, two methods have been used for
assay.
(a) Knowing the daily urinary excretion, the body content of
radionuclide is calculated from knowledge of its metabolism. The method
has worked for strontium-90 (e.g., 3 Rongelap cases at autopsy confirmed
urinary analysis (Ref. Conard 1980, Appendix, p. 115), but not so far
with plutonium where extremely small quantities are involved.
(b) The dose can also be calculated from the diet. The primary
obstacle here is that the diet is difficult to ascertain accurately. The
Livermore results are based on this method.
For Rongelap, diet and urine methods are in frank disagreement. The
Livermore diet method finds the daily intake of plutonium-239 to be
-18 pci/d (Section 4.2: plutonium-239 is 60% of the -239,-240 mixture)...
On the other hand,
plutonium-239 excretion
about 5 x 10 -3 pci/d.
than .07- pCi/d to about

the current analysis of urine at Brookhaven gives
values which range from less than 1 x 1075 to
These correspond to a range of intake from less
38 pCi/day.

The doses (30-year, whole-body) calculated from these estimates for
plutonium-239 are as follows:
Livermore:

-007 ren

Brookhaven:

»>.003 rem - 1.48 rea

The total dose for the three transuranics (two plutoniums plus americiun)
would be twice these figures.
The problems implicit in this comparison require some detailed
discussion.
Brookhaven results.
Historically, we may begin with Conard’s
twenty-year Rongelap review of 1975 (Ref. BNL 50424) in which the results
of urine analysis for 10 Rongelap persons were reported (Appendix 12,
p. 147). One result seemed much too high; the average of the other nine
was 58 x 10-9 pCi/liter/d, twice the maximum found in the current series.
Conard did not discuss this result, but it was reviewed by an ad hoc
group which suggested contamination as a likely cause of the high values
(Lessard 1984).
Urines were again collected on a much larger scale in 1981. The
PARALS method was applied, but abandoned owing to inherent contamination
with polonium. The fission track method was then adopted and a method to
separate plutonium for such analysis worked out. It should be recognized
that the very sgall quantities of plutonium involved make the operation
of the method a very difficult task (ORAU). The cost per sample is about
$1,000.

76

Select target paragraph3