3.

REASSESSMENT

With the foregoing as background, let us now attempt to answer the
questions which the Congress has asked: Were the doses used by DOE-1982
correct (Robison 1982b)? Does it follow that Rongelap is habitable? If
not, what should be done?
It should be noted that the technical position has changed since
1982. More data have been accumulated so that the original meager
sampling has become more robust. In addition, we shall consider the
findings of the Brookhaven National Laboratory, using an important method
which DOE-1982 did not consider, and also our own findings.*
The data base employed by DOE-1982 comprised the results of the
Northern Marshall Islands Survey of 1978 (September-November) which had
been planned as an aerial reconnaissance to map external gamma-ray
exposure rates (normalized to 1 meter above ground level) (Tipton &
Meibaum,1981). Two helicopters were employed, operating from a major
support vessel, the U.S.N.S. Wheeling.
Subsequently the Livermore Laboratory program was added to obtain
soil, water, vegetation and fish samples at each atoll “as time and

facilities might permit" (Robison et al, 198JZ, Part 1).

The time spent

at Rongelap Atoll permitted 7 days for 9 islands, of which the major one
was Rongelap. Operating from a large ship that had to cruise at a
considerable distance offshore, and whose primary function was aerial
reconnaissance, restricted the terrestrial work significantly.
The radionuclides dealt with were five: cesium-137, which is
distributed throughout the body;
strontium-90, a bone seeker; and the
very poorly absorbed plutonium-239.-240 and americium-241, which have
very long half-lives and which are tightly bound by bone, liver and
testes (Table 3: #1).
The Livermore group tock soil samples from some 25 scattered
locations on Rongelap Island whose averages (picocuries/gram) for 0-10 cm
depth were: cesium-137, 12; strontiug-90, 7.1; plutonium-239,-240, 2.6;

americium-241, 0.9 (Table 3: #2). These 1978 levels were about twice
those for Eneu, Bikini Atoll.

This soil contamination provided the basis for human exposure in two
ways. Radiations that emanated from the ground or standing vegetation led
to external dose. Radiations that emanated from food and water after
entering the human body were responsible for internal dose.

*

B. Franke states that the enabling legjslation calls for study of

only the original findings and report. A second committee should
consider subsequent findings, and a third group should execute its
recommendations.

19

Select target paragraph3