660

Sutow and Conard

in the proximally exposed and 6 per million
in the distally exposed children.* * Straightline relationships between irradiation doses
and leukemia incidence in the Japanese data
were noted over the dose range from 100

to 900 rads.
The British data were obtained from follow-up studies on about 15,000 patients, predominantly males of 14 years and older,
who were given radiotherapy for ankylosing
spondylitis‘! ** #1; 73 cases of leukemia have
occurred among these patients. The number
of cases of leukemia expected in this study
population in the absence of irradiation has
been estimated to be four or five.'! These patients received therapeutic doses of radiation;

therefore, “this study does not provide evidence on leukaemia incidence after doses below 500 rad.’’*? Other epidemiologic investigations have indicated that children with

leukemia have had greater exposure to radiotherapy than have comparison groups??-%*

and that children subjected to therapeutic
irradiation, particularly to the thymic area,
have a higher incidence of leukemia than
expected.* * 73? In some reported series,
however, children who received therapeutic
irradiation, including irradiation of the thymus, did not show a significant incidence of
leukemia.**-** Again, the history of therapeutic radiation is not always a significant finding in leukemic children.’ *7 The total volume of tissue irradiated (bone marrow) has
been suggested as a factor of importance.*°
Although increased frequency of deaths from
leukemia among American radiologists has
been reported,‘ 4? the data do not contribute toward quantitative aspects of the

problem.?**¢

Several attempts have been madeto determine the probability of leukemogenesis on
the basis of radiation dose.?* *4348 The
conclusions do not definitively answer the
question of the existence or nonexistence of a

threshold radiation dose for the development
of leukemia in man.*® A cause and effect
relationship, however, between high-dose
radiation exposure in man and increased

incidence of leukemia must be accepted.*°

radiation and the occurrence of malignant
neoplasia other than leukemia has been the
object of intensive scientific inquiry since the
publication of reports of increased carcinogenesis in children who wereirradiated in infancy for thymic enlargement.* > Cancer of
the thyroid gland appears to be the most
frequent malignant tumor noted in these
studies.*-7* #9 Eleven cases of thyroid cancer
developed in a group of 1,644 children given
x-ray therapy to the head, neck, or chest. In
the same population, 0.12 case would have
been expected. Irradiation dosage in the 11
children ranged from 100 to 1,770 r in air.®

In another prospective study of 2,809 infants who had been therapeutically irradiated
for thymic enlargement, 9 cases of thyroid

cancer were found (0.10 case expected) in

addition to 21 cases of thyroid adenoma (0.9
case expected). The 9 with thyroid cancer
had cumulative exposures ranging from 156
to 1,092 r in air with a mean of 598 r.’ Al-

though the development of “thyroid nodules”
has been ascribed to prior therapy with
iodine-131,** *° only one case of thyroid

carcinoma has been reported among patients

so treated.*® °° Various data suggest that the
formation of the nodules was more frequent
in children than in adults (33.3 per cent
compared to 0.84 per cent).®° Clinical observations have indicated that the history of
antecedent therapeutic irradiation to the neck
area was significantly very common (up to
80 per cent) in children and adolescents with
thyroid cancer.*® ** In the ABCC survey in
Japan, 21 instances of thyroid cancer were
found over a three-year period (1958-1961)
among more than 19,000 persons in the
study sample.*? Nineteen of the 21 occurred
in the exposed group. Two were under 15
years of age at time of exposure; 8, however,
were under 21 years of age at exposure. Tentative exposure doses (T;;), computed on the

basis of exposure distance and shielding history of these cancer cases, ranged from 125
to 3,400 rads with the exception of a single
patient whose T;; dose was calculated to
have been 33 rads.®* It was concluded from
these findings that thyroid carcinoma was
significantly more prevalent among survivors

\

|

:
:

i

‘

af
n!

i

Rest

Pe

Prat:

oSi

Qe“2Zu

Cancer. The correlation between ionizing

October 1965 |

Select target paragraph3