Dr. Libby raised a question whether Los Alamos should be criticized for being too conservative. He felt that its development program has been dominated by theoretical physicists, and that bolder experimentation would be in order, | : vos Ute : = aeiene paceman aries ve “ ES rss He also remarked on the5 quality of“poldness dn the Livermore approach, and said that if their experiments were successful they would continue to be bold, if unsuccessful no one would dare to be quite sO bold, | At 11:30 a.m, the Committee met with Dr. Smyth, Mr. Murray, Mr, Meeting Zuckert, and Mr. Nichols, with the Commis- excused from the meeting, sioners and Mr, Strauss arrived later. Mr, Tomei was Dr, Rabi asked whether the suggestion that Brookhaven be devoted General . Manager entirely to unclassified research was a serious one, and expressed the — BNL rather unfavorable initial reaction of the Committee. Entirely Unclas- Dr. Suyth replied - that he had made the suggestion for discussion, to explore whether this eee might be a way to handle the difficult. problem of foreign partiedpation, _ He rephrased the question: if one were faced with the alternatives of this step or of excluding all foreigners, which would be preferable? Dr, Rabi said that the reaction of the Laboratory should certainly be ascertained and considered before a judgment was expressed, Dr,. Smyth indicated that the matter need not be further considered at present, but might come up again, Policy on Aliens Dr. Habi next acknowledged receipt of the policy paper on aliens, AEC 89/3. . He mentioned that there had been considerable difficulty at

Select target paragraph3