metastases, is well documented (41,87,117,120,125,126,129,130,254-256, 260).
In only one case (No.

72) was there evidence of cervical lymph node metastases

from a clinically occult papillary carcinoma (see Figure 4).

Lymph node metastases note in Table 4 were all limited to regional cerviThese has been no evidence of distant metastasis in any of the
cal nodes.
Marshallese, nor has there been local recurrence of any resected carcinoma.
Other forms of thyroid malignancies, such as medullary, squamous, anaplastic,
or sarcomatous, have not been observed.
Table 5 summarizes the distribution of these tumors among exposure
The prevalence of these lesions within the study population subsets
groups.

has been discussed in Section III.1.b.

No specific type of histologic lesion

appeared directly attributable to radiation, since they occurred in similar
relative proportions in both exposed and unexposed groups, but histologic and

cytologic changes consistent with radiation injury were observed in some of
the exposed individuals. These included the postirradiation interstitial
fibrosis, lymphocytic thyroiditis, and oxyphilic changes noted by other investigators (257,258).

In a number of instances, more than one diagnosis applied to a single pa-

tient. Most of the specific lesions, such as papillary carcinomas, occurred
in a local milieu of adenomatous nodularity, but the latter was recorded as a
separate diagnosis only when it was judged to be a significant contributor to
the palpable nodularity. When carcinoma was found, it was not always the clinically suspicious nodule that originally prompted surgery, a circumstance experienced by a number of other investigators (148,153,257).
Favus et al.

(153) reported the frequent coexistence of adenomatous

hyperplasia and radiogenic papillary or mixed carcinomas.

As noted in Table

4, the present study included numerous cases in which prominently hyperplastic
foci, often with papillary configurations, occurred within adenomatous nod-

In two of these cases (Nos. 8 and 2221), focal atypia was also noted.
ules.
Otherwise, there was no histologic evidence to suggest that such hyperplastic

areas might eventually progress to carcinoma, especially since they were also
The reasons
commonly observed among the nonirradiated control populations.
for such highly localized, exuberant responses to TSH stimulation remain

unclear, however, and radiogenic injury cannot be ruled out as one potential
cause. Studies of children with thyroid exposures of <1000 rads led Spitalnik
and Straus to suggest that focal hyperplasia in such cases might represent a
premalignant alteration (258).
Many of the references cited indicate that radiation-induced papillary

or mixed carcinomas of the thyroid usually represent low-grade malignancies
with relatively little or no clinical significance in terms of patient morbidity or mortality. Factors that appear to influence prognosis adversely in-

clude nonpapillary histology, size of the primary, local extent, local recurrence rate, and distant metastases, but not regional lymph node metastases.
The single most important adverse prognostic indicator may be onset at more

than 40 to 45 years of age (41~44,45,118,119,121-123,125).

Of the fourteen

Marshallese with either occult or overt papillary carcinomas, five were in the
Of the five with cerviolder age group, three of whom were radiation exposed.

cal node metastases, one (No. 3042) was in the unexposed comparison population
from Utirik.

Since the preponderance of cases among the Marshallese was in the younger age group, and all were papillary carcinomas devoid of local recurrence or

- 67-

Select target paragraph3