Critique of British Medical Research Council
The Hazards to Man of Nuclear and Allied
Radiation

A Report to the British Medical Research Council

The British Medical Research Council is a governmental body

and was directed by the Prime Minister on 29 March 1955 to appoint a

committee under the chairmanship of Sir Harold Himsworth to.review the

existing scientific evidence on the medical aspects of nuctear: and
allied radiations.
.
This report consists of eight chapters.

The first four

chapters deal with basic understandings of radiation and its biglogical
effects, the fifth chapter with existing and foreseeable. exposures
due both to peacetime uses of atomic energy as well as to nuclear

detonatians in testing and in warfare, the sixth part with recommenda-

7

tions of permissable exposure and the seventh and sight Parts with
pummaries and conclusions.

Chapter I is an introduction to the report.

|

Chapter II discusses in simple terms the natume of radiation

and its action on livirg cells.

It deals with well known units,

methods of measurement ami biological effects.

.

ge

Chapter III discusses the effecta of radiation on the ‘pealth
of the individual. It includes discussions of the early effects

upon the Japanese at Hiroshima and Nagasaki and the later development:

ef an increased incidence of leukemia among the survivors,

The British

state they have demonstrated an increased incidence of leukemia in .
patients with arthritis of the spine treated with x-rays. They cite

also American statistics on the increased evidence of leukemia in

radiologists.

They conclude that radiations can induce leukemia byt

do not quantitate the exposure necessary for such an effeet shorof
large single doses as at Hiroshima and Nagasaki,
NAS
.

There follows a discussion of radiation as an inducer of
cancer anda conjecture that 1000r exposure to radon gas and its

daughter produces induced lung cancer in the Schneeberg and Joachimsthal,

mines,

Paradoxically, they go on to say that there is no evidence

that external x- or gamma rays can cause lung tumors in man.

There is a discussion of radiation as a cayse of bom tumors
drawn principally from the reports of eancer of bones in radium dial

workers am individuals given radium therapeutically.

is American data,

Most af this

They feel there is not much of a factor of gafety

S

ECTUOU
7 © JOUC

SAVEMY OF SCIENCES |

Select target paragraph3