86

Harold L. Atkins

hypothyroidism. Consideration of these factors may yield clues to the etiology of
post-therapy myxedema and lead to the development of methods to reduce its
incidence.

Size of gland.

In all series reviewed in which this factor was taken into

account, the incidence of post-treatment hypothyroidism was significantly greater
in patients who had small glands, either nonpalpable or of normai size.7**’ The
administered level of '*'I has been adjusted downward from the usual calculated
amountin some Series in consideration of this factor.”*
In the review of their surgical series, Nofal et al.” also described this feature,
but normal sized glands were rarely operated on.’ This may be a point of bias in
favor of surgery when attempting to compare ''I with surgery in relation to
resultant hypothyroidism.'*
Presence of nodules. The multinodular gland appearsto be moreresistant to
treatment, whether it be radioiodine or surgery. It usually requires multiple doses
of |] more frequently and has a much lower incidence of post-therapeutic
hypothyroidism.?** Surprisingly, in patients with a single functioning nodule the
incidence of subsequent hypothyroidism is greater.*’ In these patients it would
ordinarily appear appropriate to give large doses since the nonnodular tissue

would be relatively spared. However, the same results are found following

surgery.” Therefore, the incidence of hypothyroidism must be related to something other than just the distribution of radioactivity in the gland following a

therapeutic dose of "!I.

Age of patient. There is a suggestion that the thyroid of younger individuals
is more sensitive to radiation than that of older individuals and in someinstitutions
the dose is reduced somewhat for the younger patient. The study of Segal et al.*
showed a slightly higher incidence of myxedema in the younger patients. In some
series the '*‘I-treated younger patients tended to have larger glands,’ whereasin
other series these patients tended to be treated surgically. This factor can certainly

bias results. Nofal et al.’ demonstrated a slightly higher incidence of post-therapy

hypothyroidism in the younger age group with '*'I treatment, whereas the highest
incidence following surgery wasin the patients who were between 40 and 49 years
when treated.

Size of dose.

The size of the initial dose does appear to have an effect on

subsequent development of hypothyroidism and has been the basis for several
series using lower doses to control the disease.'*!*"!8 This may possibly slow the
rate of the late cumulative incidence, but it certainly reduces the incidence of
hypothyroidism in the first year. It does result in an increased requirement for
multiple doses.

an

ae)

»
Pad
af

CHG

Number of doses. There is an inverse relationship between numberof doses
(and total doses) and the development of late-onset hypothyroidism in most
studies.?*7-14 Usually patients requiring multiple doses had multinodular glands.
In addition, response to the first dose selected out those patients whose glands
were more radiosensitive.

Select target paragraph3