€

252

Radiation-Associated Thyroid Carcinoma

COMMENTS AND CONCLUSIONS

€

f

From the Marshallese experience it appears that the
greater propensity for the development of thyroid
nodularities after radioiodine exposure in the children

than in the adults is related not only to the smaller

size of their glands (resulting in larger doses) but
possibly also to the rapid growth of the gland from

1-2 grams at birth to 18 at maturity.

Other factors

such as the stress of puberty and frequency of pregnancy May also have played a role.
The lower incidence of thyroid cancer in the
Rongelapese exposed as children,
as adults,

than in those exposed

is worthy of comment.

One can postulate

that the thyroid doses in the Rongelap children (7001400 rads) were high enough to cause many cells to die
at mitosis because of lethal damage to the reproductive
mechanism and thus to reduce the number of cells at
risk for malignant transformation.

At lower doses,

as

in the adult group, a greater number of cells would be
spared for malignant transformation.
One would have to
assume that in the children's thyroids the high dose
effect overrode the possible enhancing effect of the
growth factor for cancer induction.
The high incidence
of benign thyroid tumors in the children could be due
to the increased cell destruction with greater hypofunction and increased TSH stimulation of the remaining
cells producing many small nodules.
With doses ina
still higher range (> 2000 rads?) one might expect such
extensive cell destruction to result in hypothyroidism
and, because of the fewer surviving cells at risk,

few-

er tumors.
This is the situation in patients developing hypothyroidism years after radioiodine treatment
for Graves'

disease.

Perhaps the two Marshallese boys

who developed myxedema without thyroid nodules received
doses in this higher range.
It is quite likely that the final tally of thyroid
tumors in the Marshallese is incomplete at this time
Since new lesions are still occurring.
The mean latent
period for radiation-induced thyroid tumors may be as
long as 30 years (11).
Furthermore, on the basis of

Select target paragraph3