1772

PANEL DISCUSSION ON HYPERTHYROIDISM

females there is a difference, and that the

females have a higher TBG than males,
and one can plot graphs showing this
reciprocal relationship, and I think, Dr.

Werner, you showed—andJater with Dr.
Oppenheimer—that
administration
of
steroids gives rise to elevation of TBPA
and diminution of TBG. The same thing
can occur in acromegaly. In hepatic
disease, on the other hand, apparently
because of failure to synthesize these
proteins, the normal reciprocal relation

fails to hold. We don’t really know, although we are inclined to guess that
TBPA may possibly be primary in this
relationship, but it is very hard to say at
this stage.
DR. WERNER: Lest the patient problem belost in the discussion of pathogenetic
mechanisms, I shall ask Dr. Maloof to
say a word about the metabolism of some
of the major antithyroid drugs and something about the mechanism of sensitivity
to such agents. I shall then ask Dr. Conard
to say a word about ‘I radiation effects
on the thyroid.
DR. FARAHE MALOOF, Department of
Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital,
Boston: The metabolic studies we have

carried out with the antithyroid drugs,

primarily thiourea, have shown clearly
that this drug is taken up by the thyroid
in small amounts, about 1% of the administered dose/g thyroid, and that it is
specifically metabolized by thyroid tissue
(86). We have on the basis of our studies
postulated a mechanism of action by which
thiourea inhibits the iodination reaction
(37).
I think, to go back to the first panel (1)
discussion, in which everybodystated that
the antithyroid drugs passed through the
placenta, this may not be completely
valid because the only studies that have

been done have been those with thiourea

(88). Shepard demonstrated clearly that
thiourea did go throughthe placenta of the

du ES bub

Volume 27

rat and was taken up and metabolized by
the fetal rat thyroid. Whetherthis applies
to other antithyroid drugs remains to be
seen.
Anotherpoint in regard to this problem
is that, in animals given thyroxine, the
uptake of the thiourea by the thyroid is
greatly diminished. I suppose that someone, some day, should do this experimentin
pregnant rats to see whether the administration of, thyroxine to the mother suppresses the transmission of the antithyroid drugs by the placenta, and hence
suppresses the uptake by the fetal thyroid. This may have a very important
bearing on the method which Herbst and
Selenkow have advocated for treating
pregnant women with hyperthyroidism,
namely, thyroid along with antithyroid
drugs in order to inhibit a fetal goiter
(39, 40).
None of the work that we have done

would help in elucidating the mechanism
by which these drugs produce sensitivity
in some patients.
DR. WERNER:Is there an explanation
for hypersensitivity to sodium iodide?
Allergic reactions of this magnitude have
been recognized since early days.
DR. INGBAR:Is there some special reason why you say iodide? That is what is
given to the patient, but that is not necessarily what is producing the reaction. We
know that if we give large doses of iodide
to patients, there are iodinations which
occur—probably iodinations of serum proteins, and perhaps other proteins. I think
there are data in the immunologic literature which suggest that such iodinated
protein does not havespecific immunologic
properties and that there is a good deal of
cross-reaction between a variety of iodinated proteins. This was studied a number of years ago. For example, antibodies
to iodinated diphtheria toxin would react
with iodinated albumin. Iodinated protein,
certainly, is a good antigen, and hencethere

7

Select target paragraph3