asked to serve unofficially as guides when entering the pass at Rongelap

and Utirik.

I was unaware of this request.

This is not their function

and they were placed in a difficult position because of this request.
The pass at Utirik is difficult for an experienced Marshallese navigator.
We approached that pass in the early afternoon with good visibility,
about a 2' sea, and just before high tide.
As the ship approached the
reef we noted a redfiberglass boat which I recognized as belonging to
the island of Utirik approaching across the atoll.
The boat was also

spotted by Mr. Otterman who was conning the ship and by the navigator

who was on the roof of the pilot house.

The small Marshallese boat

could have closed with the ship within 20 to 30 minutes if we had held

our position outside the atoll.
However, the decision was made to proceed without adequate pilotage.
The ship missed the Utirik pass, passing over the reef approximately 200 yards south.
Mr. Otterman claims
that the ship went through the pass.
I can provide at least five affi-~
davits from people who have been in and out of that pass repeatedly that
we were well south of the pass and passed over the reef.
Luckily, the
ship draws only about 8' of water and with an exceptionally high tide we
were able to get over the reef without encountering any obstructions.
This set of circumstances is fortuitous and, in light of the ready avail-

ability of a knowledgeable Utirik pilot, showed very poor maritime
judgment."

"During the two day loading period before we sailed, it quickly became
apparent that Mr. Otterman, who was functioning as the Captain of the
ship (although he was not the registered master of the ship) was
extremely upset about the volume of supplies that’ were being loaded by
the medical team."

“Another serious problem involving administration/public relations

that developed on Rongelap involved the distribution of candy ashore by

Mr. Otterman. Three of the most serious conditions encountered in the
Marshallese are maturity onset diabetes, severe dental caries and

@xogenous obesity.
The medical group had discussed these problems at
some length and in our preplanning had decided that we would restrict,
as far as possible, the delivery of free sugars in the form of candy
to the people.
This decision was the foundation of our initial nutritional educational program and was an integral part of the medical card
of this survey.
I think it was on the second day of our visit to
Rongelap that I noticed Mr. Otterman standing on the beach surrounded by
children passing out something from a bag.
I left the screeningprocess
aboard ship and went ashore and found that Mr. Otterman was passing out

candy and chewing gum to the children."

"The first was obviously the medical survey goals that we were
attempting to achieve, but equally important was our public relations

Stature.
I think a review of past performance of this program has
revealed that the medical care has been excellent but there have been
major problems that have arisen in the public relations area.
I consider
this a very important aspect of the Marshall Islands medical survey.
During this survey that public relations effort was compromised."
Page 6 of 13
ENCLOSURE I

Select target paragraph3