(
4085280
wwe ee
COLLECTION
SO
DOEf{MV
BOX No. ge, “Enea FS"
be 01 53°74
SATUZYILY RUNUAAFS134
ZAR
AG
OE
REPOSITORY
FOLDER
A10- bv DO
—.2¢
De ConmeD
Zhu (2/ (GP
0230105-UULM'=~R4EGAAA +
= 2301002 Jaa 74
FX USAEC/PASO/E RAY/HONU HI
TO T F MCCRAV/DIV OF OPERATIONAL
AE
SAPETY/USAEC/WASH De
2
BT
eee wm eye ee
UNCLAS/N ON ¥ D/ SUBJECT: DRAFT REPORT OF RECOMMENDATIONS
TASK GROUP. 1 HAVE THE FOLLOWING PRELIMINARY COMMENTS UPON
YOUR JANUARY 11 DRAFT.
PAGE 100s MIDDLE PARAGRAPH; THE CONCEPT OF ‘ACCEPTABLE lisitt
IS AN UNDERSTAVDABLE ONE WHEN WE SPEAK OF CHOICE FOR ASSUMEE
OR ANTICIPATED BENEFIT» THE PEOPLE OF ENEWETAK, 4OWRVER,
PRESENT A SPECIAL CASE - & PEOPLE WHO ARS TU BE OFFEREL SONE
CHOICES PERTAINING TO THE RESUMPTION OF A WAY OF LIFE WHICH
YAS INTERRUPTED FOF REASONS NOT VERY CUMPHEMENSIELE TO THEM.
WHETHER OR NOT 'sAN* WISHES TO CISPEN Sa WITH ACTIVITIES INVOLVING EXPOSURE TU IONIZING SADIATIONs THESE PEOPLE - AN IVFINETESIMAL SEGMENT OF 'MAN' ~ HAVE ALREADY SUFFERED ENORMOUSLY
BEST COPY AVAILABLE
PAGE 2 RUHVAAFS134 UNCLAS
PAGE 122, BOTTO: PARAGRAPH: I WOULD ARGUE THAT SELECTING
SITES FOR THE PLANTING OF FOOL SOURCES AND FOR DAlLLING vELLS
IS - EFFECTIVELY, AT LEAST - AN ADVISORY ACTION. WE BO NOT
THEREBY DENY PLANTING OF DEILLING OTHES LOCATIONS + Wu “AY
ENCOURAGE CONSUMPTION OF THE 'G00D' AND PYUJECTION CF THE
DEVELOP AND OTHER NATURAL
OF THE POPULATICN TO ITS
SO-CALLED ENGINEERING ACTIONS MAY NO LONGER
ENVLRONMENTs OUF
BE EFFECTIVE.
PAGE 123s FIRST FULL PARAGRAPH:
rere ee ew eee
2
»
3
>
8
=
a
S
8
IN BEHALF OF "MAN'+ OUR ONLY BASIS FOR ASKING THE TO ACCEPT
ANY RISK IS THAT WE DOG NOT KNOW HOW TO REDUCE IT Oh» FOF.
ECONOMI™ OR OTHELP REASONS» ARE UNWVILLING TO DO SC.
"B4aD's BUT AS POPULATION PRESSURES
OCCURENCES MODIFY THE RELATIONSHIT
I QUESTION WHETHEP THE 'UeSe
PARTIES' HAVE THE OPTION OF DLFERRING REHABILITATION OF THe
ATOLL. WE ARE COMMITTED - MORALLY AND PROBABLY LEGALLY TC BAFLY REHABILITATION AND RESETTLEMENT.
PAGE 123, SECOND PAPAGRAPHS COST Ix DOLLARS 15 A CONCEPT Wk
HAD BEST BE VERY CAREFUL AZOUT. TH DOLLARS ARLE UeS- DCLLARS+
THEY REPRESENT ® DEAD On GCODS AND SERVICES WHICS Ani a THLE
COMMAND OF THE GOULRNY“ENT OF THE UNITED STATES« THUS» \
SE TALK OF DOLLAF COST YS AFL TALAING SI*PLY OF TH bRDESING
OF PRIORITIES OF THE UNITEL STATES» FRO». THAT STANDPOINT AND
FROX THE POINT GF VIEv OF THE PEOPLE OF
ENEYETAA IT Tf
UAWLTAELY
PAGE 3 RUHVAAFS134 UNCLAS
THAT ANYTHING TRANSCENDS IN IMPORTANCE THE EARLY ANT SAFE REa
SETTLEMENT OF THEIR ATOLL.
PAGE 141, RECOMMEVDATION 96Cs AGAIN L BELIEVE WE SHOULE 35
CQREFUL Ii CU REFERENCE TO COST FACTORS AS NOTEL Ov PAGE 125+
SDATIOA 113 RATHER THON FECOMMEND OP COMsIT
PASE 141, RECS
OURSELVES TG A B4Ss LINE SURVEY PRIOR TO RETURN OF THE PEOPLE —
OF BNEVETAX, I TadIn gi SHOULL PLAN FOR THE SURVEY 'AT THE TIME
SUNVENIENCE OF LOGISTICAL SUPPOFT
OF RETURV'. THLE I¢ PURLLUY
%, DIFFICULTY I< #OUITIVG aNy
ULE* OF THL Vary CONSID
SDITIONARY EFFORT AT i
BELTEVe THAT
1422 RECOMARADATIU. 105 1 PEZSOXALLY DO NCT
WHE SHOULD FOSECLCOSE THE GPTIGN OF OV-ATOLL ENGINEERED STORAGE
OF PLUTOMIUM CONTONINATSi SOTLe
ee ay wee
=
L2Se-ZES 1189 -WOu BIA Aiday
ree eee
135
LeS%-Le
APA
EWD MSG. OF-39
QT
#8134
x
3
<
$.
2
2
°
&
g
2
R
R