TABLE 4: Distribution of thyroid nodule type by gender.
Male (%)

Female (%)

‘Total

Adenomatous nodules

8 (25)

24 (75)

32

Adenomas

2 (29)

5 (71)

7

Occult papillary
carcinomas

2 (29)

5 (71)

7

Carcinomas

1 (10)

9 (90)

10

Total

13 (23)

43 (77)

56*

* The total number of nodules exceeds the number of surgeries because four patients had two categories of

nodules.

children one to six years of age. Three of these
children were on Utirik (ages: 1, 5, and 6 years).
The correlation between dose and time to
development of adenomatous nodules was highly
significant (r = -0.848; p < 0.001). Although the
number of observationsis small, these data suggest
that the earlier development of adenomatous
nodules was primarily a function of higher radiation
dose to the thyroid, not age. One variable which is
not controlled for is thyroxine prophylaxis for the
Rongelap children. Prophylaxis was notinitiated

3) What was the relation of radiation dose to time
of nodule detection?
The strong correlation between higher dose
and earlier nodule developmentis shown in Fig.5.
While this graph gives an overview of the
epidemic in relation to dose, it offers little

understanding of the role of the variables that
shaped it.
The predominant nodule type was the

adenomatous nodule, the ratio of these to all

other types being 4:3. Adenomatous nodules are
not neoplastic. Therefore, Fig. 5 predominantly
describes the relation of radiation dose to nonneoplastic nodular disease.
Secondly, the
prominent association of higher radiation dose
with early nodule development is influenced by
age-related variability in susceptibility to thyroid
cancer (NRC BEIR V, 1990) and benign tumors
(Ron et al., 1989; Shore et al., 1985). The mean

age of the Rongelap people at the time of

exposure was 27.6 years, but the range of ages was
0 (there were 4 persoms in utero) to >80 years,
and susceptibility would have varied accordingly.
Inferences concerning dose and time to
development of adenomatous nodules can be
extracted from data on persons exposed at
equivalent ages, thereby controlling for
susceptibility.
In Figure 6 the time to
developmentof nodules is graphed against dose in

until ten years after exposure and after the first

nodules had been detected. Therefore, the effect of
thyroid suppression on development of thyroid

nodules was not of consideration for the first 10

years after exposure.
In addition almost all
adenomatous nodules in this group had been
identified within five years of initiation of thyroxine
suppression.
A similar age-controlled analysis for the other
three nodule types is not useful because there are
too few observations per group.
4) What was the relation between nodule
development and age at exposure?
The relation of nodule type to dose and age at

exposure is shown in Fig. 7a-d. The graphs indicate

a similarity in the age- and dose-related
developmentof all four nodule types in the Utirik
20

Select target paragraph3