subscapular area (unless he had been customarily

shirtless). However, two persons developing skin

cancer out of a radiation-exposed population of 82
(2.5%) is greater than expected if Black
population studies are used for comparison

(Fleming, I.D. et al.). Furthermore, there is a

suggestion of a temporal association, for the
cancers occurred 32 and 37 years after exposure.
Therefore, the possibility remains that radiation
exposure did contribute in a direct or indirect way
to the development of basal cell carcinomas in
these two patients.

Table 2 summarizes the thyroid nodule findings
in the exposed Marshallese through 1991. It
includes the nodule described in the preceding

paragraph, which is listed under the heading of

“Occult Papillary Carcinoma." The number and
types of nodules in the Comparison groupare also
listed in Table 2, although the U.S. Departmentof
Energy-sponsored program for surgical exploration
of palpated nodules in this group was concluded in
1985.

THYROID SURGERY FINDINGS,
1964 THROUGH1991

Thyroid nodules

Only one thyroid nodule was diagnosedin the
exposed population from January 1988 through
December1991. That nodule occurred in a Utirik
man who had been in utero at the time of
exposure in 1954. The mother was in her third
trimester at the time of exposure, her whole-body
and thyroid-absorbed doses being estimated at 11
and 160 cGy, respectively. The patient’s estimated
dose was, therefore, 11 cGy whole-body and 99
cGy internally to the thyroid, for a total thyroid
dose of 110 cGy. This patient is the first of eight
Utirrik persons exposed in utero to develop a
thyroid nodule. (Two of four Rongelap persons
who were in utero at the time of exposure have
also had benign nodules removed). A thyroid
lobectomy was performed at the Clinical Center,
The National Institutes of Health. Histological
review of the surgical material was performed by
the four pathology consultants to the Marshall
Islands Medical Program (see p. 16). Selected
comments from their diagnoses are:
Consultant #1 - “Thyroid nodule of
histologically normal tissue which contains a tiny
focus of occult papillary carcinoma.”
Consultant #2 - “Adenomatous goiter in the
colloid stage."
Consultant #3 - "Nodule with fibrosis.... No
evidence of cancer."

Consultant #4 - "Tiny occult sclerosing
papillary carcinoma.”

A summary of this patient’s hospital case is

included in Appendix C.
The patient was
returned home on thyroxine suppression.

Introduction:
Thyroid nodules and hypofunction among the
exposed populations of Rongelap and, to a lesser
extent, Utirik are well documented consequences of
the BRAVO exposure. A recent reevaluation of
external and internal radiation exposures in those
populationsin all likelihood represents the definitive

quantitative analysis of organ and whole-body
radiation dose stemming from this catastrophe

(Lessard et al., 1985). The thyroid dose received
particularly close scrutiny because of early evidence
of extensive thyroid injury and because an important
mechanism of exposure was ingestion of a variety of
radioiodines, an occurrence without precedent and
therefore with unknown consequences.
A final interpretation of the effect of fallout
exposure on the thyroids
of the exposed

Marshallese has not been possible because of the

protracted evolution of thyroid abnormalities
following radiation exposure. The incidence of

thyroid cancer has been reported to be elevated

more than 40 years after radiation exposure (Shore
et al., 1985; Schneider et al., 1978) and might
includea lifetime at risk. However, for the past six
years (1986 through 1991) only one new thyroid
nodule (nonmalignant) has been detected im the
exposed persons. Furthermore, there has been only

one new nodule diagnosed in the Rongelap groupin

the past ten years. (There have been two thyroid
surgeries for recurrent benign nodules in the
Rongelap group, but these are not included in the
statistics that follow). Although occasional nodules
will no doubt continue to be diagnosed, if for no
other reason than that thyroid nodule prevalence
increases naturally with aging,it is possible that the
recent dearth of cases represents a pause that is
14

Select target paragraph3