58

not very reliable. From our surveys of the unexposed people of Rongelap and Likiep (a nearby
atoll not exposed to fallout), the incidence appears
to be about 5%, mostly presentin older age groups
(see Figure 29 and Table 25). We haveseen a few
cases of hvperthvroidism and myxedema at the

a

= 50

=

» +0

z

= 20

1962) for the Marshall Islands, the population

8

parisons).

Data on iodine intake and excretion in the
Marshallese (tabulated below and presented in
detail in Appendix 9) indicate that iodine-deficiency goiter would not be expected in this
population.
Sample
28 Urines
19 Urines
7 Diets

(1965)
(1974)"
(1974)*

lodine, av. ug/day (range)
105 (19-279)

127 (25-266)
70 (48-152)

The urinary iodine excretion is somewhat lower

than the U.S. mean of 190 ug/day (18-483) in

1941.94 On the basis of the few diets analyzed, the

daily iodine intake seems to be within the recom-

mended rangeof 50 to 75 yg.95 These iodinelevels
are somewhatlower than would be expected in an
oceanic popuiation but are much higherthan seen
in areas of endemic goiter.96 The Marshallese diet
contains no knowgoitrogens, and diffuse goiters

(typical of endemic goiter) have not been observed.

Thehigh incidence of both benign and malignant thyroid nodules in the exposed Rongelap
people appears to be clearly related to radiation
exposure with a large component due to radiotodine in thefallout. Numerous studies on animals

have shownthat thyroid neoplasia follows exposure both to x-irradiation and to radioiodines.97-99
Such tumors may be benign or malignantand appear to be dose-dependent to some degree. The
incidence of thyroid tumorsis increased in Japanese atom bomb survivors!00-103 (Figure 43).

There is a considerable amount of data showing

that children who were given radiation to the head
and neck region for treatment of thymic hyper*The iodine analyses were done by M.T. Kinsley and DF
Leahy at BNL.

EQ Nagasak:

= 30

Majuro Hospital, but no statistics are available.
Two cases of thyroid cancer are reported from
hospital admissions for a 10-year period (1952varying between 15,000 and 20,000 during that
period. This has been estimated by Trust Territory medical personnel to be abouthalf the actual
number of cases (therefore 8 cases per 20,000
people per 20 years was used for statistical com-

(2 Hiroshima

10
Notincity

0-9

10-99
T65 dose

Figure 43. Prevalence of diseases of the thyroid. fifth examination cycle, by radiation dose and city for females

age 0 to L9 at time of bomb.(From Belsky et al. 104)

trophy, acne, and fungusof the scalp have an in-

creased incidence of both benign and malignant

thyroid lesions in later years.195-112 Reports of
tumorigenic effects of radioiodine in man are more
limited. Sheline et al.,!!3 in their follow-up study
of 250 patients treated for hyperthyroidism, re-

ported 8 having nodular goiter, of whom 6 had

been irradiated at age <20 and 4 at age <10.

Morerecently a numberof cancers of the thyroid
have been reported in patients previously treated
with radioiodine for hyperthyroidism. !14-116 The
numberof such cases reported is, however, lower
than might be expected on the basis of the widespread use of 131], perhaps because the cells are
morelikely to undergo lethal damage.!17-122
In the more heavily exposed Rongelap group
the adult thyroids received a dose (335 rads) about

twice that to the whole body and those of smal!

children (700 to 1400 rads) about 8 times that to

the whole body. On the basis of the incidence of
benign nodules in the unexposed MarshallIslands
populations examined, about 3 to 4 cases would be
expected during the 20 vears in the Rongelap exposed group, whereas 24 occurred. In the Utirik
group about6 would be expected, and 6 occurred.
Regarding cancerof the thyroid, on the basis of
Marshall Islandsstatistics, about 0.033 cases would

be expected in the Rongelap group overthe 20year period, whereas 3 occurred. In the Uurik
population about 0.06 cases would be expected,
and 1 occurred; in view of the low doseofradia-

tion it is unlikely that this case is radiation induced.
Tables 33 and 34 show the incidence and the
risk per rad in the Marshallese compared with
that in other populations for both benign and malignant thyroid neoplasms. Data on benign thv-

roid nodularity are scarce, but the incidence in

Select target paragraph3