10.

Fallout in Utah

In May 1953, Washington County, Utah, was thought to have received
an unusual amount of radioactive fallout from a nuclear test at the Nevada
test site. The exact dosage of iodine-131 from this fallout is not known
but estimates for the dose from iodine-131 to the thyroid gland range from
less than 10 rad to above 400 rad. Examination conducted in 1965 of
school children in Washington County, Utah, revealed several thyroid ab‘normalities but nothing which can be specifically ascribed to radiation as
an etiological agent. Because of the fact that Washington County residents
seem, historically, to have had a relatively high prevdlence of thyroid
disease and because children in Utah outside Washington County and in
Northern Arizona at the time of fallout showed the same frequency of the
more severe thyroid abnormalities as did the children who were in residence
within the County, it is not possible, from this particular study, to
ascribe any degree of significance to radiation exposure. If indeed the
exposures to iodine-131 from fallout through the past several years were
of significance throughout the State of Utah rather than confined to
Washington County, the question of residence in Washington County, in
May 1953, may be of little or no importance.
ANIMAL DATA
Data from animal experiments indicate that thyroid tumors originate
spontaneously less frequently and may be less easily induced by radiation
than tumors of some other organs. Thus leukemia is frequent in numerous

strains of mice, breast tumors common in rats, squamous cell carcinoma in

white-faced cattle and mast cell tumor in dogs, whereas thyroid tumors
were infrequent in all except in regions where goiter is endemic. The
two general types of thyroid tumors are:
(1) rounded, circumscribed,
benign nodules: adenomas; and (2) invasive, destructive growths: carcinomas., Adenomas do not necessarily develop into cancers but may precede
them.

Ionizing radiation, as well as a number of chemical agents, may

induce either.

Most animal experiments with radiation have been done when the ani-

mals were young, though not in infancy.

However, a limited number of

sheep at Battelle-Northwest (formerly Hanford Laboratories) have been
continuously exposed to various levels of iodine-131 from conception to
death (up to 10 to 12 years of age). These animals have shown no thyroid
tumors at dose levels giving 150 rads per year, but have shown adenomas
after several years, with accumulated thyroid doses of 5000 to 40,000 rads.
Two cancers involving the thyroid gland were seen at cumulative doses
of 10,000 and 30,000 rads. Thyroid exposures of 30,000 to 40,000 rads as
a result of single doses of iodine-131 to young adult sheep also resulted
in many adenomas after 4 to 5 years.
When rats were subjected to radiation combined with substances producing goiter (which act by reducing thyroid hormonal production and
stimulating the pituitary), a few thyroid cancers were produced by 1100
rads of X-ray. About 15,000 rads were required to produce a comparable
tumor incidence when iodine-131 was used as the source of radiation.

DOE ARCHIVES

Wt

Select target paragraph3